Photo: Inside an apple processing company in northern Italy from Arno Senoner Unsplash

Productivity is the byword of the times. Workers are not productive enough, we need to be more efficient with our time. The Cambridge Dictionary defines productivity as “the rate at which a country, company, etc. produces goods or services, usually judged in relation to the number of people and the time necessary to produce them” while the American version of the dictionary defines it as “the rate at which a person, company, or country does useful work”. So you cannot just do work speedily, that work also needs to be useful. The Office for National Statistics produces datasets on productivity by region and subregion outlining ‘output per hour worked’, and productivity is at the centre of the government’s economic strategy – whichever party is in power.

What are the implications of this push for productivity?

In 2019 I wrote about the rise of self-surveillance and the colonisation of our free time through the creation of measurable productivity targets for time we would have spent pondering or pottering.  I argued that if free time and space become seen as productive ways to improve our health and mental health, our ‘free’ time becomes yet more of the day which is designated into bite sized chunks of productivity.  In his blog post this month Chris Yuill echoed this, arguing that biohackers and maxxers have taken this to the next level, collecting data on all aspects of their lives in the hope that this will make their efforts of self-improvement more productive.

The result of this focus on productivity and measurement is that unorganised, messy, space to simply think and be is diminished.  This lack of time and space to think is endemic in education at all levels. It can be seen in the government enforced curriculums in schools, packing so much content into each year that there is little time to consolidate the facts and skills being learnt, let alone think about what they might mean.  When it was proposed in 2013, education experts and teachers raised concerns that the new curriculum would ‘bury pupils in facts and rules’ and leave no time to ‘develop children’s ability to think, including problem solving, critical understanding and creativity’.

This has proven to be the case and the government has now announced that key-stage 3 – the early years of secondary school – needs to be reinvigorated to keep children engaged and interested in learning, tackle the disadvantage gap and tackle the rising numbers of young people not in education, employment or training. Experts have long been calling out this perceived focus on quantity over quality in school education and the pressure to measure ‘productivity’. The National Association of Head Teachers came out against the 3 year GCSE creep in 2021 suggesting that the high-stakes accountability regime where schools are judged predominantly on the results of statutory assessments puts pressure on schools to focus on exams and teach to the tests resulting in a narrowing of curriculums and a reduction in time for critical and lateral thinking.  Echoing this, exam board leaders suggested that pressure on schools leads to a narrowing of the curriculum and teaching to the test, all to the detriment of education.  And all of this against a backdrop of increasing mental health problems, with 1 in 4 16-24 year olds experiencing mental distress are rising rates of anxiety, self-harm, eating disorders and depression.

The pressure to be productive and the resulting reduction in thinking time is not just impacting students. Universities’ focus on productivity improvements results in less thinking time for staff. There is increasing pressure to produce outputs and less time to undertake the, often complex and slow, thinking required to ensure the quality of these outputs. These pressures are not new, an article by Menzies and Newson published in 2007 showed how academics in Canada used on-line technology to balance increased demands and time pressures.  In struggling to manage conflicting organizational and temporal priorities, they suggest that “academics are adopting practices to manage these conflicts which adversely affect the quality and content of their teaching and research”. They call for academics to fight to retain ‘temporal practices’ which allow thinking time. Building on this, in 2016, Ulmer called for academics to engage in ‘slow ontology’ with a focus on quality rather than speed and being ‘differently productive’ rather than unproductive.  This echoes the call from Berg & Seeber in their book ‘The Slow Professor’, for academics to resist the “accelerating pace and corporatization of academia by adopting principles of the Slow movement to improve teaching, research, and well‑being”.

All of this is exacerbated by the push to use AI in everything we do. AI ‘helpers’ appear when we write emails, open documents, search for information on the internet or go on to journal websites. We are explicitly encouraged to use these tools to create precis for us of the information we would previously have actively searched for, read, digested and then used in our work. We are told we no longer have to think about how to communicate with colleagues and students, AI can write our emails for us in the appropriate tone for the message being communicated. AI can read papers for us, and potentially write them too, it can analyse our data, and it can do all of this more quickly and efficiently than we can. The results may be incorrect, but as long as we check them we still save time. We are being more productive and getting through work more quickly.

But, in doing so we are helping to create what Yuill refers to as the ‘emptiness at the heart of what may be called post-neoliberal culture’.

In education the fixation on productivity makes it harder for children to become inspired and passionate about different topics and discover what it is that fascinates them, that they want to know more about, and to make links between what is being learned and what it means.  Academics are expected to create knowledge and new ways of thinking about and understanding the world but have little space to work out what their research actually means and why it might be important.

Ironically as I am writing this there is a global outage of Microsoft 365 which means I have no access to my email, teams or online files. Luckily I have a large pile of books waiting to be read and thought about.